Wikia

Resistance Wiki

WatchlistRandom pageRecent changes
Comments20

Book Review: Resistance: A Hole in the Sky

Drgyen September 10, 2011

TheSixthAxis writes a somewhat positive review on Resistance: A Hole in the Sky.

Those of you who finished Resistance 2 will remember Joeseph Capelli blowing Nathan Hale’s brain out with a well placed shotgun blast. During the course of the new book, Resistance: Hole In The Sky, Nathan remains resolutely dead but his consciousness is alive and well in Capelli’s head, commenting on his actions and generally being a bitchy queen.

There’s no indication in the book whether this bodiless version of Hale is a figment of Joseph’s imagination or some Chimera weirdness that will result in Hale returning during the course of the game via a Bones/Spock mind meld. Whatever the eventual outcome, this is not the Nathan Hale we know. He’s bitter, spiteful and downright nasty. After being executed by his best pal he may have some reason to be a little peeved, but the massive shift in character from hero to grumpy ghost is hard to swallow.

With Ghost-Hale aboard, the book explores the tale of Capelli who has been discharged from the army after the incident (apparently the Army frowns on blowing out your best friend’s brains) and spends his time as a runner, delivering packages across the wasteland previously known as the United States of America. The ruined landscape is as much a character as Joseph and writer William C. Dietz has done a wonderful job describing the destroyed cities and desolate countryside.

The plot zips along at a fair pace but does seem to take its cues from computer games – Go to point A, collect item B, go to point C, protect donkey D – and drops in numerous battles with both Chimera and humans. New characters include Nathan Hale’s sister and Doctor Malikov, one of the main characters in Resistance 3, makes a few brief appearances.

All your favourite Chimera appear during the course of the tale and many weapons from the series are used, I was particularly impressed when the Alt-fire modes of weapons were accurately described.

Overall ‘Resistance: Hole In The Sky’ is one of the better tie in novels as it nicely fills in the missing months between Resistance 2 and 3, this should be an essential purchase for fans.

  • Showing 7 most recent

20 comments

 
10.8.56.52Anonymous User
Log in?
  Loading editor
  • I thought the book was atrocious--its only real value is as an approximation of how many cliches one can stuff into a video-game tie-in and get away with it. The writing is mostly colorless, and the author does not have the artifice to be consistently novel, prevent the use of anachronisms, or even to enlarge his pitiful vocabulary with a thesaurus. He has no sense of connotation, with many words being laughably out of place. Do not get me wrong--I adore Resistance. I just think that whoever was responsible for hiring Mr. Dietz should have at least looked at the horrible reviews his other books have gotten on Amazon.

  • I thought the book was atrocious--its only real value is as an approximation of how many cliches one can stuff into a video-game tie-in and get away with it. The writing is mostly colorless, and the author does not have the artifice to be consistently novel, prevent the use of anachronisms, or even to enlarge his pitiful vocabulary with a thesaurus. He has no sense of connotation, with many words being laughably out of place. Do not get me wrong--I adore Resistance. I just think that whoever was responsible for hiring Mr. Dietz should have looked at the horrible reviews his other books have gotten on Amazon.

  • hey random question: when i am playing online and shooting at an enemy, my character will randomly melee, getting me killed. anyone else having this problem?

  • I hope I like this more than I liked Gathering Storm.

  • In the middle of the book, I personally like it but thats just because ill take anything I can get thats to do with Resistance, but I do see lots or errors with the story.

    • There were some errors I noticed. Such as a minor reference to the USA in WWI which never happened and LOTS of real weapons that were thrown in. I mean some these guns are post-WWI and can't see how they became as they were inspired from that war and present in an alternate history setting.

    • I thought they did fight WWI in the Resistance universe? Wasn't it WWII that they didn't fight?

    • Actually, World War I is known as the "Great War" in Resistance. The US didn't enter because of a very strong isolationist sentiment and there was NEVER an overt threat to the US.

    • Yea World War 2 was never fought because of the Iron Curtain in Russia, I think, or to do with that. Anyways WWI is technically called "The Great War" in reality, up here in Canada anyways :S

    • The "Iron Curtain" is actually the RED Curtain. WW2 never happened because the people working the Treaty of Versailles got their wits together in preventing another war to happen. Germany was economically stable and on good relationships with the Allies. The Nazis did formed but failed to gain a following and were ridiculed for their ideals.

    • I personally think that (if we're comparing our universe to the resistance universe) wherever the Chimera spawned from in Russia was destroyed sometime in WW2. Since WW2 didn't happen in their universe the Chimera were able to grow into power. Thank god for WW2, guys. If it didn't happen we'd have aliens on our hands!

  • Has the author of the article played the games? He thinks Hale was killed by a shotgun and thinks Fyodor Malikov and Susan Farley/Capelli are new characters.

  • It was a .45 Caliber Handgun NOT a shot gun that killed hale.

Advertisement | Your ad here

Latest Photos

Add a Photo
1,521photos on this wiki
See more >

No recent blog posts. Write one now!


What are Wikia Blogs?

Wikia community blogs allow you to contribute a blog post to any wiki's Community Blog.

Blogs are used by wiki communities for fan fiction or original work, news and announcements, questions or recommendations to the community, or reviews or op-eds. Check out Fallout Wiki's News Blog and Lostpedia's Theories Blog to see two examples.

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki